The Stories We Inherited : A Civil War Inspired Story
by DD RUMBAUGGH
Summary
My mother was the first person to tell me that our family had ties to Society Hill, South Carolina. She also said that people in our family had once enslaved others. I remember both stories, but I cannot name the relatives she meant or say who first told her. Unlike the things I know about my father because I saw them myself, this history came to me through someone else’s memory. A name may survive while its relationship to the family is forgotten; a detail that began with “I think” can sound certain after passing through generations. I want to preserve what my mother told me without pretending I already know whether every part happened as she heard it.
Society Hill gives me a place to begin, but not yet a family line. My mother also believed we were related to Ike and Billy Clanton, names that are easy to remember but do not explain how the connection ran. With Society Hill, I do not even know which branch of the family she meant. I wish I had asked her who told her, what names she knew, and how far back she could trace the story. Now I can begin with what I have: my mother’s account, the town she named, and questions about the people who lived there before, during, and after the Civil War. If records reveal that my relatives enslaved people, I want to learn the names of those people and look for what became of them and their families.
The map led me to more than one name. Society Hill lies in Darlington County, and the historic district also includes Welsh Neck and Long Bluff. My mother might have meant the town itself or the surrounding countryside. The state’s account describes an early library society and houses built before the war, some with two stories and broad front porches. Such houses suggest the lives of people with money, but they also raise other questions: who cooked, washed, and cared for the children, and who cared for those workers’ children?
The census records reveal a sharp divide across the war. In 1860, enslaved people were often listed anonymously under the enslaver’s name, identified by age and sex. By 1870, household members were named. A woman might appear by name in the later census, with children listed beneath her, yet there may be no clear way to identify her among the anonymous entries of 1860. Freedmen’s Bureau records may help bridge that gap. Some document marriages; others record agreements to work for wages. A marriage recorded after emancipation might mark official recognition, not the beginning of a couple’s life together.
An unexpected lead came from a marriage settlement dated June 4, 1856, nearly five years before the Civil War. Julia R. Gregg lived on a five-acre Society Hill lot inherited from her father, and the settlement made arrangements for the lot and other property when she married John J. McIver. Its published summary lists furniture, a carriage, horses, and people held in slavery: Nancy, Norman, Lucy, Mariah, Enoch, and two entries named Harriet. The repeated name needs checking against the original deed; it may refer to two people, or the summary may have repeated it. The settlement also covered children the enslaved women might have in the future, treating those unborn children as property.
I do not know that Julia or John was related to my family. The document is evidence about Society Hill, not proof of my own connection. It gives a name like Nancy’s a place in the record, but not her parents, children, later name, or life after emancipation. Any Nancy found in a later census or labor contract would need more than a first name to establish that she was the same person. Other names from the settlement, a familiar location, or a connection to a household might help make the case.
Another Society Hill name appeared in a study of education in the Pee Dee region. A report from December 1866 listed Etta Payne as a teacher there. In Darlington, Black residents contributed money and labor toward a new school building; their contribution was valued at $500. That figure represents both resources and work, but the account leaves me wondering how families decided what they could give and what it meant to build a place for their children to learn. I remember my mother enrolling me in kindergarten, when I was excited and frightened by the prospect of walking through the school door. I had never thought about who made that classroom possible. I would like to know who studied with Etta Payne, and whether Freedmen’s Bureau teacher reports preserve anything about the people who came to learn.
The search for names also led beyond Society Hill, to a newspaper notice placed by Clara Bashop in Chicago in 1892. She was trying to find her daughter, Patience Green, who had been twelve when she was sold in Richmond in 1859. Clara also sought news of her son, John William Harris, who had gone away after the Confederate surrender at fourteen. More than thirty years had passed since she last heard from Patience. Clara could give readers the names and ages her children had when they were separated, though either child might now be known by another name. I do not know whether she heard from them. Her notice makes me consider that a census can show who lived in a household on one day, while a search notice may reveal who was missing from it.
To connect my mother’s story to records, I will have to build the family tree from her outward, one generation at a time. A marriage record may identify a woman’s maiden name; a census may place her in a household before marriage. Differences in ages or names require comparison with other details, not a convenient guess. Estate inventories may name enslaved people, while wills may show who inherited land or other property. Those same records can speak differently to descendants: one family may trace land ownership, another may find a name and a clue to where an ancestor was taken. I need to keep my mother’s remembered account distinct from what documents establish, and leave a name in pencil until the links are supported.
In March 1865, war came close to Society Hill. Union troops on the road to Cheraw heard an explosion at ten in the morning. Powder and ammunition had caught fire, killing and wounding people and burning the town’s business district. According to one army report, infantrymen had been resting nearby while teams waited to cross the river. The blast shook the ground for miles, and the startled teams bolted, injuring some of the men driving them. The report follows the soldiers through the afternoon: they reached Cheraw around two, began crossing the river by four, and continued through the night. It cannot tell me when news reached Society Hill, or what my own relatives were doing. I still cannot place one of them there on that day.
I find myself wondering about Nancy, whose name had appeared in Julia Gregg’s marriage settlement nine years earlier. I do not know whether she was near Cheraw in 1865, what news reached her, or whom she could trust. The scene that follows imagines one possible night in her life; Nancy’s words, actions, and encounters are fictional, not historical evidence. In that imagined scene, news of Union soldiers in Cheraw arrives by rumor, with one person saying they have crossed the river and another insisting they are gone. Nancy remembers Ruth, a woman who once worked beside her and cared for her when she was sick, before Ruth was sent away. Holding directions to Ruth’s house in memory, Nancy decides to go. She leaves with cornbread wrapped in a cloth and slips past a wagon on the road. At Ruth’s house, a girl opens the door. Nancy asks whether she can stay until morning, and Ruth lets her in. Only then does Nancy discover Ruth has a daughter, Lydia, who sits by the hearth with the cornbread while Ruth begins to tell how she chose the girl’s name.
The story imagines what happens after Nancy meets Ruth and learns that the girl at the hearth is named Lydia. The following morning, Nancy hides in Elijah’s house when the wagon driver arrives at the footbridge. He questions Elijah about what Ruth saw the night before, while Lydia is sent inside with an empty meal sack. Once the driver has gone, she tells Nancy that Ruth sent her to warn that he plans to come back after dinner. Nancy must keep going. Elijah knows of Hannah, a woman beyond the old orchard who has taken in his cousin, and offers to show Nancy the way. Before Lydia returns home, Nancy makes sure she has eaten something, so Ruth will receive more than a vague promise that she is safe. Lydia insists she can carry the meal, and Nancy lets her carry the message about her dry socks and food.
At Hannah’s house, Nancy struggles to explain why she has come and asks whether Ruth and Lydia could join her if they needed to leave. Hannah says she can make room for all three. She writes a short note offering Ruth and Lydia a place, if they want it. Nancy asks Hannah to put “Nancy” at the bottom. Hannah first demonstrates how to hold the pencil, then turns the paper toward her. Nancy presses too hard, but manages to write her name. She has never written it before. She sends the note with Elijah, asking him to read it to Ruth exactly as it is written. Later, Lydia arrives with news that Ruth is coming. She also brings a brass key: it opens Ruth’s back door, and Ruth has decided not to return for it. Nancy closes her hand around the key, while Lydia explains that her mother sent her ahead and is waiting for Elijah.
Ruth soon reaches Hannah’s, carrying a bundle. A wooden spoon falls from it; Lydia had carved her initial, an L, into its handle. Ruth tells Nancy the wagon driver went to find help, and she waited for Elijah so the man would discover an empty house. When Nancy offers the key back, Ruth tells her to keep it. Lydia rushes to her mother, and the three settle in for the night. But the wagon returns with another man. Hannah directs them to a path behind the orchard, leading toward a creek and a washhouse. Nancy takes the key from beside Lydia’s cup, and the group slips out the back.
At the gate, Lydia’s bundle catches on a nail and tears. The spoon drops, and Lydia turns back for it just as a man appears around the house. Nancy waits until Hannah draws his attention, then retrieves the spoon and eases the gate shut. They cross the creek and reach the washhouse. When Lydia asks whether Nancy wants the key back, Ruth says she does. She has carried it long enough; now, if they need it, they will ask her for it. Ruth, Lydia, and Nancy continue with Elijah, while the spoon remains tucked into Lydia’s bundle.
On the way, Ruth admits that her husband was sent away before the cold weather and had said he would try to return. Now she fears he will go to the old house looking for them and think they left without him. There is no safe way to leave a note there, since the wagon driver has already been inside. Ruth suggests that Mrs. Bell, who lives beyond the mill and knew her husband, could keep a message in her memory and deliver it if he came by. Lydia has her own message: her father should know she still has the spoon and has carved the L deeper so it will not wear away. She also wants him to know that her mother came back for her. Ruth tells her she was always coming, but understands why Lydia wants him to hear it. Elijah carries their message to Mrs. Bell.
Three days later, Elijah returns with news. Mrs. Bell says Lydia’s father arrived the day before, hurt his foot on the way home, and is resting at her house. He asked whether Lydia still had the spoon, remembering the flat place on its handle where the knife slipped. He hopes to meet them at the sycamore the next day. Ruth doubts he will stay put and asks Nancy to write another message: he must wait, because she is coming. Lydia asks to be included, and writes a large L at the bottom. While Elijah carries the note back, Lydia asks Nancy whether her father will look the same. Nancy tells her she is probably wondering the same thing about Lydia. The girl wants him to see how much taller she has grown.
At Mrs. Bell’s, Lydia first sits on a rock to remove her shoes and stockings, hoping they will be dry for the reunion. Her father waits on the back steps with his injured foot bandaged. When she recognizes him, she runs to him, then worries she has hurt him. He tells her where to sit and takes the spoon, feeling for the L carved into the handle. Lydia shows him the old fold in the hem of her dress and then stands straight so he can see how she has grown. Ruth joins them. She and her husband say nothing for a moment, then she sits beside him and leans into his shoulder. Mrs. Bell gives Nancy back the note. Lydia’s father had kept asking her to read it and wanted to know which part was Lydia’s. Elijah arranges a handcart so the injured man can travel without walking, and Lydia puts the spoon in his coat pocket, promising to take it back when they reach their next stop.
The family’s reunion is tender but does not make them safe. Mrs. Bell warns them that two men were near the mill, and the group prepares to leave by a lower path. As they set out, Lydia’s father asks to be taken somewhere he can lie down. A loose wheel and the weight of the cart slow them. Elijah pulls, Nancy steadies the cart, and Ruth stays close to her husband. Lydia keeps checking that the spoon remains in his pocket. Then voices carry through the trees. The group stops, and Nancy sees a strip of blue cloth caught on a thorn. She recognizes it as part of Lydia’s braid and turns back toward the snag.
Nancy frees Lydia’s blue ribbon from the thorn and slips it into her pocket. Nearby, the wagon man and another searcher are looking for the group. When they move on, Elijah leads the cart off the exposed path and down an old timber cutting. The descent is steep; the cart slips, Lydia’s father cries out, and the group must keep moving despite his pain. At a bend, fresh boot prints point toward them. Then a voice calls Elijah’s name. It is Hannah, who has come by way of the lower path. She brings urgent news: the wagon man has been asking for Nancy, “the one who can write her name.”
The words make Nancy think of the note she wrote for Ruth, inviting her and Lydia to come if they wished. She has kept it close, but another scrap has turned up at a fence: her name, written in a different hand. The writing below it is blurred, and Elijah can make out only a possible word. They cannot tell who wrote it or how it came to be there, but the paper makes the danger tangible. Nancy’s name can now travel ahead of her, into the hands of people who have never met her. When the group reaches an abandoned shed, Lydia asks whether Nancy could erase her name. Nancy answers that it is pressed too deeply to rub away. Ruth cannot tell her whether to burn the note; Lydia’s father advises her not to decide while frightened.
With daylight fading and his injured foot worsening, the group must find somewhere to rest. Nancy and Hannah approach a house beyond a field, where a woman named Esther is sewing by lamplight. Esther hesitates when they ask for shelter, but she sees Nancy’s bandaged hand and agrees to help. In the kitchen behind her house, she gives them a place to bring Lydia’s father and begins tending his foot. When hoofbeats sound on the road, they darken the room and listen as a man asks Esther for a woman called Nancy. Esther refuses to be hurried into answering. When he demands to know whether she has seen anyone, she makes him explain his business and insists he show her the paper bearing Nancy’s name. He leaves without learning who is hidden in the kitchen.
Esther recognizes that the searchers may return, and arranges to take the group to her sister, who knows more about treating injuries. The travelers leave through the orchard, guiding the cart between crooked trees and over rough ground. At a fork, they follow the track by a fallen tree and wait at a gate, as Esther instructed. A woman emerges from the orchard carrying a basket. Her name is Miriam. She examines Lydia’s father and brings the group to her home, where she cleans and binds his foot. When Miriam asks what happened, the injured man looks toward Ruth, but before he can answer, Elijah admits that he witnessed the encounter.
Elijah explains that the wagon man stopped them on the road and questioned them. When Ruth’s husband said he needed to get home to his family, the man deliberately brought his boot down on the injured foot. Elijah had tried to help, but the man ordered him back. Elijah obeyed at first, and says he keeps remembering that moment. Ruth asks why he never told her. Her husband reminds him that he came back, and the simple acknowledgment halts Elijah’s self-reproach. Lydia gives her father the carved spoon she has carried throughout their flight. The small object belongs to the story’s imagined world, as do the characters’ words, choices, and journey.
At dawn, after Miriam has cared for the injured man, the group leaves the orchard. The narrator steps out of the fictional journey to state plainly that the 1856 marriage settlement is the historical record: it establishes that a person named Nancy was listed there, but it does not establish that she wrote her name, fled through the woods, or had any of the relationships imagined in the story. The document cannot reveal where she went or what became of her. The scenes make the human stakes of that silence imaginable, but imagination cannot turn a possibility into evidence. The responsible response is to keep asking what other records might name Nancy, while leaving unanswered what the surviving record cannot tell.
The narrator then returns to the family stories inherited from her mother, Doris Ann Clamton. Her mother spoke of ties to Society Hill and of a possible connection to Ike and Billy Clanton, but the remembered claims are clearer than the relationships behind them. Even the family name requires care: her mother’s name is spelled Clamton, while the famous name is Clanton. One letter separates them, but the narrator does not know what the difference means. Rather than choosing the spelling that makes the appealing connection seem obvious, she records both and leaves room for evidence.
The Society Hill account requires the same restraint. “Our family” might refer to a direct ancestor, a relative by marriage, or a branch whose history became part of the family story over time. Until the people and generations connecting that account to the narrator’s mother can be established, she cannot responsibly attach it to her own line. Familiar surnames, shared names, and striking historical associations are clues, not proof. A family tree must be built from documented links, one generation at a time, and the inherited account must remain distinct from what research can verify.
That discipline includes keeping track of sources: who shared a memory, what they knew, and where doubt remains; where a document came from and how it can be found again. The narrator wants to preserve her mother’s words without treating every detail as established fact, and to record gaps as gaps. She knows now that a story can contain a mistaken name, a missing generation, or an uncertain relationship—and that the honest account may simply be: her mother told her this, the connection has not yet been established, and she is still looking. At the top of a page she writes her mother’s name, Doris Ann Clamton, and begins with what she knows.
Want the Full Experience?
This summary includes Key Takeaways, Chapter Summaries, Notable Quotes, Who Should Read This, and a professional AI-narrated audio version — available with a paid listing.
The author can upgrade this listing to unlock all sections.