In Their Shoes: A Journey of Understanding and Supporting Depression
by Pamela J Wells
Summary
Pamela Wells begins with the story behind the questions she would later ask others. Raised in a Christian home, she learned early to hide her sadness behind a mask of being fine. Her strict parents left her feeling unable to speak about problems or question authority, and when she was five, her father began sexually abusing her. Her mother provided for the children but showed little affection; Wells believes she did not know about the abuse. For years, Wells kept her pain suppressed, and depression surfaced only occasionally.
After marrying Layne in 1980, she had two children and built a life with him. But in 2007, when routine tests led to his quintuple bypass surgery and a frightening series of complications, Wells was terrified of losing him. She held herself together while he was ill, then found herself weakening as he recovered. From the outside, there seemed to be every reason for her to feel happy: Layne was getting better and returning to work. Yet she could not explain why she felt so sad. Earlier, she had heard him dismiss a news story about postpartum depression with the advice to “talk yourself out of it,” and worried he would not understand her own struggle. A pastor recognized that she was in trouble, encouraged her to see a counsellor, and urged her to tell Layne. Her husband listened and supported her.
Finding a therapist who could help took more than one try. The first ended treatment after two sessions; the second kept returning to a subject Wells felt she had already dealt with. A third therapist proved a better fit and worked with her over several years, helping her uncover painful childhood memories. Understanding more about her past did not, by itself, lift the depression. Suicidal thoughts, present since she was nine, became more focused, and she eventually told her pastor. With her permission, he spoke with her therapist, and Wells was hospitalized. She spent weeks in hospital, later attended Homewood Health Centre in Guelph, and received therapy and medication. Even with substantial care, she attempted suicide in May 2011, after a difficult Easter weekend left her feeling that hope had vanished. She survived, but still wanted to die. In June, she took part in a time of focused prayer and came away with a sense of peace she had not felt in a long time. Wells believes her faith played a role in her recovery, but stresses that her experience was her own, not a route everyone should follow. She also cautions against treating her personal account as medical guidance. Finding professional support that feels right may require trying another therapist.
To broaden the picture beyond her own life, Wells gathered responses from people aged seventeen to sixty-seven, including people she met in hospital and friends who volunteered. She changed their names to protect their privacy, noting that stigma made some participants reluctant to be identified. She asked how depression feels, what worsens or eases it, and how people want others to treat them. Her aim is not a clinical explanation but a collection of lived experiences: depression has common threads, yet no single story represents everyone.
For Wells, depression is like an ugly, familiar coat: uncomfortable and unwanted, but so worn that it can feel strangely safe and difficult to remove. It is also like a deep pit. She can see light above but lacks the strength to climb toward it, even when someone offers encouragement or a ladder. Katherine describes suffocation, paralysis, and a dark hole; Grace reports exhaustion, isolation, intense emotion, and feeling unable to move. Others speak of life becoming overwhelming, of withdrawing from friends and family, sleeping, crying, or losing the energy to cook and clean. Some experience suicidal thoughts; others do not. Sam explains that a person may still speak and act positively while privately believing the worst, partly from fear that honesty will invite mockery or disbelief. A person need not be visibly deprived or facing an obvious crisis to be depressed; life can look good to outsiders while feeling unbearable within.
The answers about what makes depression worse reveal how easily attempted encouragement can deepen shame. Wells felt like a failure when people quoted scripture at her or told her she had a good life. Katherine was hurt by being called a “psycho”; Barbara resented sarcastic commands to get out of bed and find a life. Others recoiled from “get up and get going,” “just get outside,” “stop crying,” “snap out of it,” or comparisons with what helps the speaker when they feel blue. Such comments imply that depression is a choice, or that a person’s circumstances should make the illness impossible. They can leave someone feeling unseen, blamed, and even less willing to ask for help.
What helps varies just as much. Wells valued hugs and simple expressions of love or prayer, rather than an attempt to find perfect words. Katherine wanted to hear that she was loved and needed. Barbara drew comfort from reminders of God’s presence, while Grace said she had been alone. For Sam, a concerned question such as “How can I help?” could open the conversation, especially if it showed genuine willingness rather than pity. Emily appreciated being told that someone would listen or help her reach a professional; medication prescribed by her doctor also helped her. Deb valued knowing someone was there, even when she could not take in encouragement. Liz acknowledged that, in the depths of depression, nobody could say something that would immediately make her feel better. Care may matter even when it cannot make the pain disappear.
Asked how they wanted to be treated, Wells describes a tension many respondents share: she wanted to be left alone, yet longed for a sign that her friends remembered her. An email, call, or hug would have mattered. Some wanted respect, dignity, and compassion; others needed time and space. Sam observes that a person may say they want solitude while secretly hoping someone will keep trying, because they need reassurance that they matter. Emily insists that depression is a genuine problem, not a character defect or a failure to pull oneself together. Deb wants room to withdraw without having others take it as rejection, while still receiving love and support. Their answers point toward care that is steady but not presumptuous: stay present, respect the individual, and let them know they remain welcome.
What people with depression do not need is to be mocked, pitied, talked down to, or treated as though they are incapable. Pamela disliked teasing intended to cheer her up, pitying looks, and unsolicited advice. Katherine did not want to be treated as handicapped; depression had not taken away her intelligence or her right to be treated like an ordinary person. Barbara objected to being told she should stop taking Zoloft, as if relying on medication made her a drug addict, or that depression was “all in her head.” She had learned that her prescription helped steady her emotions, and the illness was not something she invented.
Grace wanted privacy, not pity or probing into her personal history. Sam warned that dismissing a person as merely seeking attention could be dangerous: nobody else can know exactly what is happening inside someone’s mind, and even a bid for attention may reveal a deep need. Emily did not want to be ignored or told to snap out of it. Deb did not want people to treat her as fragile, lecture her, or assume they knew better. Liz feared being avoided as though depression were contagious, and rejected the suggestion that she was simply imagining her symptoms. Across their different answers, the contributors describe how judgment, disbelief, and condescension can add shame to an already painful illness.
Social situations can be difficult in sharply different ways. Pamela would arrive at church late and leave early to limit interaction, while shopping and other outings became hard to tolerate for more than about two hours. Katherine sometimes felt unable to leave home for work, or had to abandon her grocery cart and go home when anxiety in the store felt like a heart attack. For Barbara, by contrast, spending time with good friends and working full-time could lift her mood and restore self-worth and confidence. Grace struggled with crowds and with family gatherings, where an hour was often all she could manage; even coffee with friends could sometimes feel like too much.
Sam described the contradiction of wanting connection and dreading it. In a large gathering, he hoped to find someone with whom he mattered, yet expected to hide behind jokes, technical help, or familiar entertainment. He feared not people themselves so much as the emotional strain of performing around them while still feeling alone. After a rare, successful outing, solitude could help him absorb the good experience; too much isolation, however, fed a downward spiral. Emily found it painful to be around people whose lives seemed to include what she lacked, such as a happy marriage or family. Deb found large parties especially difficult when she knew few people, and Liz often avoided social events because she dreaded questions and advice about what she should do.
A helpful invitation does not have to mean pressure to attend. Pamela wanted to be included, even when she might decline, and appreciated being told she was welcome but free to stay home. Katherine found commitments stressful: if anxiety kept her from going to an event—or to work—guilt could make everything worse. Barbara sometimes wished someone would come and distract her, though often she had to seek company herself. Grace enjoyed people who made her laugh and visits with her children and grandchildren. Sam did better with brief events than with hours-long gatherings, which gave him less time to lose hope that he would connect with someone.
Others preferred low-key time together: Emily suggested a movie, dinner, or a walk with few people around, while Deb liked one-on-one visits, coffee, a movie, shopping, or dinner, with the occasional more adventurous outing. Liz treasured invitations from her adult children: her son asking her to visit or stay for a weekend, and her daughter offering lunch or breakfast, or coming over to cook dinner. These examples show why one fixed prescription—always get out, or leave the person alone—cannot fit everyone. The form, length, and pressure of an invitation can matter as much as the invitation itself.
The question about suicidal thoughts brought out experiences that were not interchangeable. Pamela sometimes wanted the pain to end and often fantasized about suicide. Katherine remembered wanting to die from her early teens, though at other times she wanted only the pain to stop; she knew friends who had died by suicide and still struggled to understand why some people survived and others did not. Barbara described thoughts driven at different times by unbearable pain or a wish to get even with someone who had hurt her. Her faith and awareness of the people who loved her helped her resist, and she believed medication kept her more level.
Grace had attempted suicide during a frightening crisis in her marriage, jumping from a second-storey window and suffering lasting spinal damage. Sam had wanted to die and had attempted to cut his wrists, while also fearing death and worrying about how an attempt would affect his family and the little hope he had left. He compared the emotional struggle to pressing a hand against a brick wall: logic could tell him he mattered, but his feelings would not yield. Emily had written notes and imagined being free of emotional pain, though she did not think she would seriously try. Deb had experienced thoughts of suicide during some periods, without taking them further. Liz did not have suicidal thoughts, but often imagined hiding alone in a dark closet. The variety matters: depression does not automatically mean suicidality, and distress does not always take the same form.
When asked what signs they wished others would notice, Pamela recalled sleeping more and giving away possessions that were special to her. Katherine hoped close friends might notice when she was sad and help distract her. Barbara named sleep and withdrawal; Liz mentioned quietness, short answers, avoidance, and sleeping all the time. Deb might become unusually quiet or emotional and turn down invitations she would normally accept. Emily wished people would notice when she stopped doing activities she usually loved.
Yet signs are not always easy to read. Grace had asked her mother to take care of her young children because she needed help, but her family was in denial and afraid to face what was happening. Sam often worked hard to hide his distress, letting only occasional hints escape, with no consistent pattern for others to recognize. Even outwardly capable or cheerful people may be struggling privately, and someone who says they are fine may be unable—or unwilling—to explain what is wrong.
For caregivers, the contributors offered no single formula, but returned often to the value of steady friendship: show affection, offer company or distraction without insisting, and make clear that you care. Katherine suggested hugs, lunch, shopping, or time with the children, while also believing that a healthy lifestyle and positive relationships mattered alongside medication. Her view was personal, not a universal rule. Grace urged unconditional love through setbacks and mistakes, and described how treatment at Homewood helped her begin to feel safe and learn to communicate after a lifetime shaped by childhood abuse. Nature, she said, could be therapeutic for her; she might sit watching birds or water for hours.
The stakes of responding to distress can be frightening. Katherine recalled a neighbour who told her he intended to die by suicide. He later hanged himself while his young children were home. She carried guilt, wondering whether she should have called the police or an ambulance, but the story also shows how overwhelmed and uncertain a friend can feel. Barbara’s advice is to offer care without claiming the power to control another person’s recovery. Emily similarly urged caregivers not to take withdrawal personally, to keep expressing love, and to make room for their own respite. Deb recommended learning the signs and listening, while accepting that no one can save everyone. Her point is not to withdraw, but to support without making oneself solely responsible for an outcome.
Sam’s guidance was to resist playing hero or delivering a speech full of psychology, doctrine, or solutions. Listen, ask what the person wants and what they think might help, and accept “I don’t know” without treating it as the end of the conversation. Ask again later. Liz urged loved ones to learn about depression, accompany someone to a doctor if invited, and be honest when they do not understand but want to. Mary, whose adult son Ted had struggled for years and attempted suicide, described how depression affected the whole family; she wanted to understand his signals and respond with support rather than fear or helplessness. These accounts underscore that caregivers need information and support of their own, too.
Other contributors widened the picture. Amy remembered shame and silence around her depression, even after treatment, and believed that speaking more openly would reveal how many people were struggling. George and his wife emphasized sleep, managing stress, nutrition, exercise, and enjoyable activities as parts of their own efforts, while noting that individual needs differ. Neil described trying to cope alone, pushing away his girlfriend, then turning to self-harm, drugs, alcohol, and repeated suicide attempts. Betty, who could seem bubbly, said she felt empty inside and wanted understanding without demands. Delores recalled that a friend who came over, cried with her, and prayed beside her helped more than instructions to “get out more” or simply surrender her sadness to faith. Patrick stressed that depression may arise from very different circumstances, and that friends and family should learn about it without pressuring the person.
Wells reflects that depression can quietly erode hope until a person can no longer imagine an end to the suffering. She describes different forms and causes: distress after a partner’s affair, seasonal depression, experiences associated with genetics, or a need for medication to regulate emotions. She recalls an analogy of depression as a bubble of sadness and despair that never dissipates, leaving a person isolated and trapped. No one pattern or remedy fits everyone. Her own belief in a spiritual dimension comes from her personal experience, but she does not present it as an explanation for every person’s illness.
Her practical counsel begins with learning about depression and taking it seriously as an illness, rather than a failure of character. A task that seems simple to an outsider may feel impossible to someone who is ill. Loved ones can be patient, kind, and willing to listen; remember that irritability or withdrawal does not define the person underneath; and avoid interpreting a reduced sex drive as personal rejection. If medication is involved, they may help the person keep track of it, without taking the place of medical advice. Above all, reach out in whatever way the person can accept, remind them that they matter, and love them without making them feel blamed. If someone speaks of suicide, take it seriously and seek immediate help; do not dismiss it as attention-seeking. Wells warns caregivers not to let compassion become self-erasure: set limits and seek support, while continuing to care.
She illustrates that care through small, tangible acts. In a television story, a friend brought soup to a frightened young woman who had shut herself away after an assault. The soup was bad, but the visit opened the door to company and conversation. The friend returned with more, promising not to stop. Wells connects this to her husband, who stayed close when she pushed others away, and to friends who gave her space without abandoning her. A postcard she mailed to a distant friend arrived on the day that friend was preparing to take her life; its goofy picture made her laugh and interrupted the moment. Wells cannot know what would otherwise have happened, but the gesture mattered. When her father was dying, family friends repeatedly brought apples from their orchard. Their note acknowledged that the family might not need more apples, but wanted them to know they cared. The gift was less important than the persistence behind it: do something, because something is better than nothing.
For someone experiencing depression, Wells offers modest ways of moving through a day: take life one day at a time, seek laughter, consider a hobby or group, move in whatever manageable way is possible, and make room for rest. Spend time with people who love you, keep a journal, and notice good things as well as painful ones. She also suggests volunteering when it is manageable, though her own reflections stress that severe depression and anxiety can make leaving home feel overwhelming. These ideas are possibilities, not demands or a cure. Wells is not a clinician, and her story is not a treatment plan. Professional care can matter, and if a therapist does not feel like the right fit, seeking another is acceptable. Support, whether it comes through treatment, friendship, faith, or a small reminder that someone has not been forgotten, should meet the person where they are.
Want the Full Experience?
This summary includes Key Takeaways, Chapter Summaries, Notable Quotes, Who Should Read This, and a professional AI-narrated audio version — available with a paid listing.
The author can upgrade this listing to unlock all sections.