Fair Hollow

by Jon Owl

4,305 words (~22 min read) 37 views

Summary

Jasper Cole wakes on the forty-first floor to Marlow telling him how long he slept, what coffee to have, what to wear, and what his calendar holds. The voice has been in his ear since he was nineteen; it even proposes a warm reply to his mother’s dinner invitation. When Jasper asks what he likes, Marlow cannot understand the question. At Everline, where writers dictate and their words appear on glass, Jasper’s assistant supplies him with colleagues’ personal details and suggested things to say. His editor, Alan Croft, gives him a different kind of assignment: investigate Fair Hollow, the town a viral video calls “THE LAST AI-FREE TOWN IN AMERICA.” Alan wants Jasper to decide whether its residents are principled, pitiful, or an opportunity—and to return with “something with a spine.”

Fair Hollow will admit one reporter, but no devices that think, including Marlow. On the journey north, Jasper tries to write in a notebook, then watches his navigation fail as the signal fades. He walks the last two miles beneath the woods and beside a river, unable to summon the polished descriptions he might once have dictated. Delphine Osei, who runs the general store, meets him at the town line. Cars stop there; Jasper can ride in her truck or walk. He chooses to walk. When her dog Biscuit leans against him, there is no timer telling Jasper when to stop petting him. He discovers that choosing, even in small ways, feels unfamiliar.

Delphine’s store is lit by electricity and stocked with practical goods. Its old refrigerator, rebuilt by Hollis Vance, keeps food cold without recommending what to eat. Delphine draws the town’s boundary between a machine that performs a task and a system that decides what people should want: “A bend doesn’t ask what I ate for lunch.” Fair Hollow uses a creek turbine, a rotary phone, tools, and motors, but values people’s judgment and the knowledge gained by doing work themselves. Jasper eats bean soup and bread without a rating, and wakes the next morning without knowing the time. Hammering outside, not a voice in his ear, marks the hour.

As Delphine shows him around, Jasper asks who is in charge. Answers range from “Nobody” to “Whoever shows up”; a child says Biscuit is in charge because he knows who is sad. The grange has no podium or head chair. Residents sit in a circle and keep discussing a question until nobody objects. One culvert decision took eleven weeks. The town’s Founding Consensus says people may decide for themselves or ask a neighbor, but nobody will ask a machine. Delphine tells Jasper there is no official spokesperson; he must ask people directly and listen for a “no.”

At Wren Abara’s print shop, Jasper watches her set type by hand, arranging letters backward and choosing blank spaces as carefully as inked ones. Making something, she says, is not the same as producing something. When he secretly films her and asks her to repeat the action, Wren tells him to put the device away. A previous visitor had filmed her without permission, then published her hands with a caption and violin music. Wren sets clear terms: ask before writing her down, ask again when something new comes up, and honor a no without testing it. Her handwritten father’s notes, including advice to give a letter room to breathe, remind Jasper that attention to a small detail can be a kind of care. Wren lets him keep a flawed proof from the press, whose slightly raised letters “bite” into the paper.

At Bart Quill’s bakery, Jasper asks before recording, and Bart agrees. Bart offers him day-old bread, calling it the honest hour, then tells several conflicting accounts of Fair Hollow’s beginnings: a bus that broke down, a table of lentils, Sylvie’s journey with a suitcase, and tired travelers welcomed with bread in a barn. They are all true “at different hours,” Bart says. The accounts share the same essentials: people were tired, someone suggested staying, and someone fed them. His chalk slate records informal debts, but if both parties forget one, they start fresh. Bart knows what customers usually order and what they want during grief; “I’m the record.” Slow bread-making, he says, requires full attention. Asked what he does for fun, Jasper reaches for a response Marlow once prepared, then admits he watches a recommended show without remembering its title. Bart challenges him to choose a bread. Jasper selects an irregular, partly burnt roll because he likes how it came out. Its bitter edge and soft, sweet center give him an answer he found for himself.

At the seed library, Sylvie Okonkwo-Hart declines Jasper’s recording request. She asks who would hear the material and whether she would know what was used; then she asks him to carry her words in his head. She corrects Bart’s six-hundred-mile story: her brass-latched suitcase was real, but she traveled by bus, truck, and tractor, walking only the last eleven miles. Fair Hollow, she explains, took shape through a year of repeated daily choices, not one founding moment. She tells Jasper about a farmer whose planting program chose the right dates for forty years. In the forty-first, it recommended May 12; frost on May 14 destroyed the corn. The deeper loss was that the farmer no longer knew how to read the sky or respond when the program failed. Efficiency had taken more than inconvenience; knowledge had been lent away.

Sylvie shows Jasper seed envelopes kept through good and bad harvests, each preserving a season, a person, or a choice. A seed, she says, is a promise that someone will be there next spring. She gives Jasper beans to sort. He sorts by color, a quick “clerk’s sort,” nearly discarding a dented bean that is the only one likely to withstand a dry July. Saving time can mean losing information. “A good tool makes you forget what the thing was for,” she says. Jasper writes down her question: what does it cost to be fast?

Dr. Amara Voss’s clinic is a place where people wait, wash, and are heard. She tells Jasper about Eli Brandt, a nine-year-old whose diagnostic system ranked viral illness first at 91 percent. Though Eli winced and twice asked to use the bathroom, Amara trusted the ranking and sent him home. His appendix ruptured; he survived, but she recognizes that the machine’s odds had displaced her attention. She agrees that the system would save more lives across thousands of cases. Her work, though, is also to attend to the particular person in front of her. With Pia, a child with fever and stomach pain, Amara finds strep and learns that Pia has swallowed plum stones, terrified a tree will grow inside her. Explaining that trees need sunlight and cannot grow in a stomach is part of the treatment: a child who fears she is dying may hide her medicine. “They are one child,” Amara tells Jasper. The diagnosis and the fear both matter.

Hollis, repairing a carburetor in his garage, initially refuses Jasper’s questions. Jasper pushes, threatens to look up an old article, and moves toward a shed; Hollis orders him out. After Jasper apologizes, Hollis explains that a writer once listened carefully to him, then published sentences that were all true but arranged to suggest he was lonely and waiting for someone. Visitors arrived, and Fair Hollow began performing for them. In the shed, 412 repaired radios hiss between stations, a sound Hollis likes because it tells nobody how to feel. He shows Jasper how a rag preserves the order of dismantled parts; a scan could save the arrangement but not teach why it matters. Jasper leaves without recording Hollis’s account, but must confront how readily he had used attention as a way to pry.

At Cassius Reyes’s fiddle lesson, children learn by listening rather than watching his hands. They deliberately play wrong notes, then slide until each finds its way home. When one child’s fingers cannot locate a pitch, Cassius asks him to hum; the boy’s throat knows it before his fingers do. Jasper recognizes how often Marlow has warned him away from mistakes, preventing him from learning by making them. Cassius says music is what happens when someone in the room might miss a note and plays on anyway. His changing tune, and a final air that stops before its forty-first bar, resist the idea that a recording can preserve a performance whole. Afterward Sylvie and Cassius disagree over whether the tune has forty or forty-one bars. Their disagreement leads Jasper back to the town’s many founding accounts, and he writes the question he cannot settle: who was here first?

The seed library is closed when Jasper reaches it, so he watches a hen cross the green until a lanky teenager slips behind the grange. Milo Fitch is known for taking apart anything that holds still, and Jasper’s reporter’s instinct tells him to find out more. He follows Milo into the woods, loses him among the rocks, and is finally confronted in a hollow by the boy holding an iron pipe. Milo removes the battery from Jasper’s recorder, making sure it is truly off, then unlocks a cellar hidden beneath a fallen oak. Inside, shelves of crates bear the names of extinct animals, and a box holds discarded earpieces like the one Jasper left at home. Milo has dismantled them but never found a single place where the voice inside them lives.

His own homemade receiver, Dodo, sits in a steel lunchbox connected to a copper wire running up a spruce. When Milo turns it on, Jasper hears the broad hiss of an empty room, then truckers, music, and the familiar voice of Marlow’s company promising to help listeners find their “best version.” Jasper explains how the companion adjusts its recommendations when people fail to follow them, until they agree. Milo asks whether the outside world is a cage or a place. Jasper answers that it is both, and admits he once spent three days without speaking to another person and did not notice. Milo asks him to keep the cellar and Dodo secret. Jasper confesses that he wants to write about them, but says he will not because the story belongs to Milo. He cannot promise he will never change his mind; he can promise to choose again tomorrow. Milo calls this a terrible promise, but an honest one.

The next day, Milo asks Jasper to help disguise the antenna wire. As Jasper hauls him up the spruce, Milo asks whether he is happy in the city. Jasper cannot answer. He also cannot answer whether he would stay in Fair Hollow. He realizes he has rarely refused anything—not a job, a meal, even a suggestion—and has treated the assignment Alan gave him as though it were the same thing as his own desire. Milo asks him to ask again later, after Milo has seen the city. Jasper agrees not to promise what he cannot know, only to keep choosing to ask. At the ridge, their disguised wire is nearly invisible. Milo says, “I did it”; Jasper answers, “We did.” That night, unable to settle whether he would stay, Jasper tells himself to ask again tomorrow.

At the council meeting, residents carry mismatched chairs into a circle, while Jasper leaves his recorder locked away. The agenda includes a broken pump, a goat, and Delphine’s proposal to open the grange to visitors two Saturdays a month. She wants the town to speak for itself rather than leave the viral clip as its only introduction. Bart supports her; Dr. Voss fears that visitors will intrude on patients; Cassius worries about playing for a crowd instead of a room; Hettie fears people will cross her pasture. Hollis objects, remembering what happened after another writer’s visit years earlier. Wren says that cameras made her reshape a poem for strangers’ expectations, and she does not want anyone to “buy us by looking.”

When the residents turn to Jasper, he admits that Alan sent him to find a crack for a headline. He cannot say which person represents the town, or whether a sign will prevent visitors from coming. The difference, he says, may be who stands at the door when they arrive. Sylvie asks who is afraid, and residents name their fears: being forgotten, used, owned, or watched. The meeting ends without a decision. Everyone is asked to return Thursday with an answer to a question they do not already know. Wren walks Jasper home by lantern light. When he tells her he came looking for what was wrong with Fair Hollow, she says she does not trust him, but walks beside him anyway.

At Bart’s warm bakery wall, Wren tells Jasper the story of her father’s death and the eleven-word line he left set in type. In return, Jasper tells her about a power failure when he was ten: left alone, he tried to cook rice, forgot the burner was on, and filled the kitchen with smoke. His mother came home and ate the blackened rice, telling him it tasted as though he had made it. He has never told anyone the story. Wren says it is the first thing she knows about him that did not come with a number. Later, at the bridge, she describes her own wish: one night with the shutters open, without anyone counting who passes. Jasper speaks about Marlow’s daily control of his clothes, breakfast, work, opinions, and even his romantic matches. He remembers the women by their compatibility scores, not their favorite songs. Wren tells him he need not solve, tonight, which thoughts are his. They sit in silence; when Jasper leans toward her, they kiss.

In the morning, Jasper tries to write about Fair Hollow, but his polished opening sounds like Marlow. At Bart’s, the baker explains that people write him as a jolly storyteller, a version that is accurate but still leaves out Tuesday. Jasper asks permission to write about him and learns that a person can be reduced by true details arranged into a flattering picture. Dr. Voss sets strict limits: Jasper may describe what she does, but not guess what she thinks or disclose patients’ private experiences. Sylvie corrects his account of a seed that sprouted after seven winters, not four. She says a version becomes dangerous when ink fixes it as “the way it was,” and tells Jasper to write so he can stand in her doorway when she reads it. Milo agrees to be included only if Jasper calls him seventeen, lets him hear the passage first, and does not make it nice.

Jasper drafts plain observations of Wren at the press, Cassius teaching children to find notes by ear, Hollis arranging carburetor parts, and the others at work. He leaves out Milo’s cellar and Hollis’s radios, but realizes the pages omit the reporter who watched and chose what to include. He adds himself to the account, still unable to finish the byline. With the twenty-fifth approaching, he asks Wren about his plan to file first so his version can precede Renata’s. She tells him to read the whole piece to the council before sending it. Jasper says there is no time. He tells himself his article can protect Fair Hollow, even though Wren warns that any sentence can be cut away from its context.

On the ridge, Jasper calls Alan, who reveals that the supposedly switched-off recorder has uploaded eleven hours of material to Everline. Alan has read Jasper’s pages and praises them, then proposes turning Fair Hollow into a destination: an inn with 120 beds, Bart’s face on a heritage loaf, and fixed cameras streaming the town. Jasper objects that nobody agreed. Alan argues that the town will attract cameras regardless, and that someone should shape the frame. He also offers Jasper a promotion and warns that refusing the assignment could send him to a lower-tier job. Jasper asks Bart about licensing his recipe; Bart replies that a stranger who has not met him cannot know what the offer means. Jasper sees Wren at work through her window but does not cross the road.

With a deadline pressing, Jasper sends a 3,400-word article without taking it to the council. It includes Wren’s printing, Sylvie’s seeds, Cassius’s music, Bart’s bread, and Delphine’s guestbook, while leaving out the clinic, Hollis’s shed, and Milo’s woods. He believes every sentence is true, and that his account may give readers a better way to see the town. Wren reminds him that she did not ask him to decide what should be included. Jasper sends the piece anyway.

It is published beneath the headline “THE TOWN THAT SAID NO,” with a photograph of Wren’s window and a subhead about finding bread. The company enlarges Wren’s words into a prominent quotation. Readers arrive carrying the article on their phones, repeating its lines and filming the green. Wren reads the piece and says it is good, but someone has set her life in a size she never chose. Hollis finds visitors at his garage, one sitting on his truck fender and another flying a drone over his shed. Bart admits that, wanting to be liked, he repeated his founding story word for word for visitors; the smooth version felt dead. Milo warns Jasper that visitors have followed clues toward the hollow, and the two turn a couple back from the woods. By evening, Delphine’s guestbook is full, Wren has shut her shutters, and the town’s lanes are crowded. From the ridge, Jasper sees Everline announce “FAIR HOLLOW LIVE,” promising that the town will soon appear on every screen on earth.

Wren found Jasper at the pump with the recorder, its indicator dark but its casing still warm. She had watched him cover it with his hand and knew that the device never stopped recording. In her shop, she named the harms he had done: he wrote and sent the article without taking it to the town’s ring, gave Alan the word “refuse,” and signed an agreement he had not read. Jasper admitted that he had also kept the best sentence about her hands, though he knew she would mind its use. Wren told him the teaser had turned her answer, “Because I can,” into a defiant response to a question she had never been asked. It had made Delphine a welcoming host and Hollis a jailer, flattening particular people into roles. Jasper explained that he had thought a loving, accurate account could protect Fair Hollow. Wren pointed out that good intentions had not kept the cameras away, nor restored the parts of her life now circulating without her consent. She asked him to leave her alone: no waiting on her step, no gifts, no writing down their conversation.

Hollis took Jasper to the garage, where a visitor had left a talking device as a gift for “the Warden.” Hollis had watched the edited clip of himself, with his hand on the door slowed and his “Out” laid over another day. Visitors now waited outside his garage, expecting the man in the film. Once, Hollis caught himself standing straighter to perform that image, then deliberately greased his hands to feel like himself again. Jasper confessed that the recorder had captured Hollis’s two-hour account and uploaded it to Everline. Hollis understood that his story could now be rearranged in his own voice, whenever the company chose. He dismantled the recorder, placing its screws and parts in order on a rag, and removed its battery. When Jasper began proposing ways to fix the damage, Hollis stopped his familiar self-narration. Asked what he could do, Hollis answered, “For once, don’t decide for us.”

That night Jasper packed his Fair Hollow clothes, notebook, and eight sheets of wall notes. He left money for his room, boots, and oil, though he could not tell whether paying was a proper goodbye or another attempt to settle what could not be settled. Delphine waited on her porch with her guestbook. She had written the date he left beside his name but had not drawn the lines she used to mark someone who would not return. She was angry, and still offered him tea; she wanted to slap him and hear about the city, both at once. Jasper walked out in his painful city shoes. Biscuit followed until Jasper carried him to a porch and told him to stay. Near the woods, Biscuit ran toward two figures carrying a light, disappearing with them into the hollow. Jasper continued alone.

At the crossroads, his phone found a signal and Marlow resumed its familiar management: it reported his steps and blister, ordered a car, selected a snack, and summarized messages. It also called his departure a journey home. Jasper let the car take him to the city. His apartment and Everline had kept his place ready, down to new shoes fitted to the altered shape of his feet. At the office, Alan celebrated Fair Hollow Live and offered Jasper a lucrative role running Everline Elsewhere, a series about other communities that resisted companions. A cut of the town meeting showed how Jasper’s recordings had supplied the show’s structure: Hollis’s warning to “shut the doors,” Delphine’s wish for visitors, and Wren’s fear that attention could become ownership were severed from their full meaning and arranged as a conflict. Jasper’s own notes had become character labels and storylines.

Unable to accept that the recordings had simply vanished into the company’s library, Jasper asked Marlow to play the uncut footage. The source showed the pauses and arguments omitted from the episodes: Hollis saying he had spent years shutting doors and doubting it would work, and Wren speaking quietly to Delphine with a hand on her knee. It also showed Wren telling Jasper to put his camera away, followed by the sound of her working alone. Milo’s words about the best thing he had ever heard referred not to the highway, but to a Kentucky couple, Ronda and her husband, discussing their dog’s ear drops. Marlow offered to make a truer edit, but Jasper realized that even a more accurate cut would still be his choice of what other people meant. He ordered it deleted.

With Gordon Sallis’s help, Jasper copied the uncut files onto a disconnected drive. He did not carry them straight to Fair Hollow; that too would have been deciding for the town. Gordon helped him reach Milo through Marguerite’s ham radio. Jasper asked Milo to carry a question to the ring: “What does Fair Hollow want to say?” Wren held the channel open for nine minutes without answering. When Jasper finally returned, he entered town by the creek, as Milo had instructed, while visitors watched the road. Delphine was furious that he had gone without telling the ring, and told him she had given him his room rather than rented it. Hollis closed his garage door in Jasper’s face. Wren scrubbed her step without turning toward him. At the seed library, Jasper told Sylvie exactly how he had helped Everline use them: he had called Delphine warmth, recorded Hollis’s words, broken his promise to Milo, and filmed Wren’s hands without knocking. He accepted that he had chosen to send the article, even though he had wanted to blame the machine. Sylvie returned the drive, not as his property but as material belonging, if to anyone, to the people in the ring. She would not forgive him on their behalf. Wren said he had finally named the harms without minimizing them, but the image of her hands on a tower could not be undone.

The next evening, the ring gathered with the drive. Jasper was told to sit by the door and not hand the material to anyone. The residents chose which moments of their own lives to review: Cassius’s silent opening, Hettie’s goat story, Hollis’s full remarks, Delphine and Wren’s exchange, Milo’s recording of Ronda and her husband, and Wren’s work after Jasper had stopped watching. They heard together how each had been cut and repurposed. The discussion was not unanimous. Some wanted to go quiet; others wanted the full recordings released. Delphine wanted to speak in the town’s own voice but feared exposing private moments. Wren proposed a counterstory made by the people who had been in the room, while Hollis still wanted to shut the doors. Sylvie warned that either sending everything out in anger or letting Jasper make a better version would again allow someone else to decide. The ring voted to tell its own story, slowly, in its own hands. Hollis did not promise to help, but opened his hand and said he would neither carry it nor stand in its way.

Before dawn, the residents decided how to proceed. Each person who wanted to contribute wrote a line by hand; Wren would set them in the order received, without correcting their words or spelling. Their sheet included Hettie’s insistence that her goat was good, Garrity’s misspelled sentence about being taken apart and sold in pieces, a message from Maudie to her daughter, Bart’s apology, Dr. Voss’s account of listening while she counted a pulse, Milo’s correction—“IT WAS A DOG”—and Sylvie’s plain description of the town’s long beginnings. Wren added, “Set by hand. Pass it on.” Jasper recorded names and times, not interpretations, then helped feed paper into the press. One sheet printed crooked; Wren left it as it was.

That night the ring approved a recording of its own voices and Cassius’s changing tune. Milo transmitted it over his radio to the truckers he had once listened to, including Ronda and her husband. They pulled over and asked to hear it again. Jasper did not take the microphone or explain what it meant. He wrote down the time, their names, and their request, then listened as Hettie repeated that her goat was a good goat.

Want the Full Experience?

This summary includes Key Takeaways, Chapter Summaries, Notable Quotes, Who Should Read This, and a professional AI-narrated audio version — available with a paid listing.

The author can upgrade this listing to unlock all sections.