A Fisherman's Tale

by Denn Guptill

3,557 words (~18 min read) 35 views

Summary

Stupid, stupid, stupid! He said I would do it, and I did it. Then, to add insult to injury, the rooster crowed. I turned and looked Jesus straight in the eyes, and my world fell apart. It seemed I had known him forever, but had I ever known him at all?

It had started three years earlier, when Andrew and I were mending nets on the shore of Gennesaret. We’d had an ordinary night’s fishing, and all I wanted was to get home to Esther. My family had worked these waters for generations; fishing was in my blood, even if it meant sleeping while my wife began her day. Andrew, my younger brother and business partner, caught me staring at the same patch of net and asked whether I was weaving a blanket for Esther. Then he brought up the Messiah again.

Andrew believed the signs pointed to the Messiah’s arrival. I teased him: people had been saying the time was right for three hundred years, and this time everyone seemed to think John the Baptizer was the one. But John himself said someone greater was coming. Andrew could keep chasing his hopes; I had a boat to mend, a wife to see, and sleep to catch up on. Rome ruled Israel, as one foreign power had after another for centuries, but I wasn’t convinced a Messiah would solve anything.

At home, Esther welcomed me with breakfast and affection. We shared our house with Andrew and Esther’s mother, Marion, whom we had taken in after her father died. Children had not come for us, and caring for Marion gave Esther something to do with the ache of that. She understood why Andrew sought a purpose beyond fishing, even if I complained that a partner ought to pull his share. When Andrew failed to come home for dinner, I was ready to send Esther’s brother Eli to find him. Instead, Andrew burst in with news: he had found the Messiah, and the man wanted to meet me.

Andrew told how he and Philip had been listening to John preach repentance. John suddenly called Jesus the Lamb of God and urged them to follow him. Jesus had then told Andrew to fetch his brother, though Andrew hadn’t mentioned having one. I figured the whole town knew we were brothers, and I doubted a carpenter from Nazareth could be the Messiah. Still, I agreed to meet him, warning Andrew that if he kept neglecting the boat, Eli might replace him.

Jesus greeted us as if he had expected us, though I had only decided to come moments earlier. In the room was another Simon, who wore a patch over one eye and told a stirring story about losing it fighting the Romans. The truth was that he had blinded himself as a boy in a stick-sword game. He preferred the heroic version because it stirred people against Rome. Jesus called him the Zealot, and challenged him: if he followed Jesus, “kind of true” was not good enough. The Zealot wanted rebellion; I wanted no part of it. I was a fisherman who loved his life and his wife.

Jesus said the problem went deeper than Rome and that his movement would change the world without swords or bloodshed. He asked whether I was content to catch fish or wanted to change the world. I didn’t know what to make of him, though his confidence and his way of speaking held my attention. We talked and laughed for hours. At the door, he said he would call me Peter, partly to distinguish me from the other Simon, and partly because the name suited me. I thought changing a man’s name after one evening was peculiar.

Esther was curious about Jesus, and I tried to reassure her that I probably wouldn’t see him again. Yet the thought of him stayed with me. Andrew kept calling me Peter, and weeks passed without any word from the carpenter. Then, after a night’s fishing, Andrew spotted a school of fish close to shore. We waded in with our nets. As we finished, Jesus appeared, looking thinner and sunburned, his hair and beard grown long. He asked if I was ready to catch people instead of fish. When I asked what that meant, he simply told me to let Eli finish up and follow him.

John and James were nearby with their father, Zebedee, a sour-tempered man who seemed to demand more from his sons than from his hired workers. Jesus called them too. Zebedee warned them not to leave, but they went anyway, saying the hired men could manage. Jesus joked that their nickname, the Sons of Thunder, suited them, given their father’s stream of curses. Then we cooked fish and talked. Jesus spoke about things I had never really discussed aloud: what God wanted from me, and how impossible it seemed to satisfy everyone’s demands. His answer was simple: love God and love others. I told him it couldn’t be that easy. He only smiled.

He wanted me to leave fishing and travel with him as a disciple. I explained this to Esther: we might be gone for days, but Jesus said we should trust God, and Eli could manage the business. Esther asked how we would survive, and whether I truly meant to leave home. I couldn’t say where this path led, only that I had to take it. She told me to do what I wanted, the words every married man knows are not quite permission.

The next day Andrew arrived, still imagining that Jesus would free us from Rome. Instead, Jesus told us about the wilderness where he had spent forty days preparing for his ministry. He said he had fasted, without food or water, and that the Devil had come to tempt him. I wondered whether hunger and heat had made him hallucinate, but Jesus insisted the encounter was real.

First, the Devil urged him to turn stones into bread, challenging him to prove he was God’s Son. Jesus resisted, answering that people do not live by bread alone, but by God’s word. Then the Devil took him to the temple’s highest point and urged him to throw himself down, twisting Scripture into a promise of protection. Jesus replied that God must not be tested. Finally, the Devil showed him the kingdoms of the world and offered them in exchange for worship. Jesus refused: he would worship God alone. The Devil, he said, was still the same schemer he had always been, and still believed he could win. Then Jesus looked at us and asked whether we were ready for an adventure.

The news of John’s death had barely settled when the crowd found us in the field. One moment we were alone with Jesus; the next, people were streaming in from every direction, pressing close to be healed. Jesus moved among them, opening blind eyes, straightening twisted limbs, and giving a child who had never spoken the words to ask for a drink. Then, as the numbers grew too great for him to reach everyone, he climbed to the highest point in the field and began to teach. Thousands settled down to listen.

His message was about forgiving those who had wronged us, and refusing to seek revenge. He spoke of the burden that resentment places on a person, and how forgiveness makes room for grace and love. I wondered whether he was preaching to himself as much as to the crowd. The day passed quickly, and as the sun began to set, Andrew pointed out that people were getting hungry. I expected Jesus to send everyone home. Instead, he said we should feed them.

There were thousands of men, not counting the women and children. I told Andrew to search the crowd for food, although I couldn’t imagine there was enough to matter. He came back with a boy named Jacob, whose mother had packed him five rolls and two small fish. Jacob offered his lunch to Jesus, explaining that his mother always packed too much because she was afraid he would go hungry. Jesus thanked him and asked if he might share it. Thomas pointed out that the food would barely feed Jesus, let alone the rest of us.

Jesus told us to find baskets and have the crowd sit in groups. As people settled among neighbours and strangers, he reminded them that God loved them and would care for their needs. Then he thanked his Father for the food. I watched him take an empty basket, and when he handed it to me, it was full. The food kept coming. We carried baskets from group to group until everyone had eaten, and when we gathered what remained, all twelve baskets were full again. Jesus sent Jacob home with a basket so his mother could see he had eaten, and asked us to take the rest to the poor.

That evening, Jesus stayed behind to be alone, while I took the others across the lake. The water had seemed calm when we set out, but darkness fell, the wind rose, and the waves began to batter the boat. The sail threatened to tear loose, and we worked desperately to keep the boat facing into the wind. Matthew got everyone bailing water, giving the frightened men something useful to do. I kept hold of the rudder and wondered whether I would ever see Esther again.

Then the wind began to die. A strange glow appeared on the water, and I thought it might be the ghost of a sailor drowned there. Before long we realized it was Jesus, walking toward us across the lake. He called out that everything would be fine, and I shouted to ask if I could walk on the water too. He said I could. I climbed out of the boat and took several steps toward him, amazed at what I was doing. But when I noticed the storm still raging around us, I started thinking about how impossible it was, and the water became water beneath my feet. Jesus grabbed me before I sank. He told me I had started well, but needed to trust instead of thinking my way out of faith. Then he walked me back to the boat, and we continued across the lake.

Not long afterward, Jesus announced that we were going to Nazareth, the town where he had grown up. I had never been far from Capernaum, and as we travelled away from the lake, the countryside seemed to lose its colour. Along the road, a leper came toward us, his body badly damaged by disease. I was frightened and wanted to keep my distance, as did the others. Jesus reached out and touched him. The man, Joash, had not been touched in years. He told Jesus he wanted his life back: to embrace his wife and hold his children. Jesus said his faith had made him well, and before our eyes Joash’s twisted fingers straightened, his face was restored, and his voice became clear. Jesus knew his name and urged him to go to the priests, be declared clean, and return home to his family. He asked Joash not to tell people what had happened, but simply to live well and remind them how much God loved them.

Nazareth was a small village surrounded by vineyards, olive groves, and wheat fields. Jesus seemed to know everyone there. His mother, Mary, welcomed us into her home, though she had not expected a crowd of guests. That evening, we met Jesus’ brothers and sisters and listened as they laughed over memories from their childhood.

Our welcome changed after the Sabbath service. The synagogue leader asked Jesus to read from Isaiah. He read the promise that God’s Spirit would empower someone to bring good news to the poor, freedom to captives, sight to the blind, and release to the oppressed. Then Jesus said that the Scripture had been fulfilled that very day. At first the people listened with approval. Then someone objected that Jesus was only the carpenter’s son, a local boy they had watched grow up. Their admiration turned to anger, and they pushed us toward the door. Jesus said a prophet was not honoured in his hometown, and led us away.

His brothers and sister were angry too. They feared the talk his words would stir up and worried about what the villagers would say about their mother. Jesus explained that he had not meant to make their lives harder, and said we would leave after lunch. Mary, however, decided to go with him to Capernaum, where she could stay with her cousin Naomi. Jesus pointed out that this was her decision, not his, and that his brother Jude, already living in the family home, would have to learn to cook and clean.

Back in Galilee, Jesus taught the crowd what life in God’s Kingdom would look like. He said God blessed those who knew their need of him, those who mourned, and those who were humble. Those who longed for justice would find it in God; the merciful would receive mercy, and the pure in heart would see God. Peacemakers would be called God’s children, though following this way could bring persecution. This was not the kingdom the Zealot and Judas had imagined. They expected justice to come through defeating Rome. Jesus warned that violence only breeds more violence. If a Roman soldier forced someone to carry his equipment for a mile, Jesus said, they should go a second mile. If he demanded a cloak, they should offer their shirt as well.

People objected that Romans would slap them for the smallest offense. Jesus told them to turn the other cheek. The law’s command of “an eye for an eye” had been given to limit revenge, he explained, not to excuse it. Loving one’s neighbour was not enough if it meant loving only those who loved us; God’s people were called to love their enemies too, treating others with the respect and kindness they themselves would want.

Then Jesus pressed the point beyond outward behaviour. Murder began in hatred and contempt; adultery began in the thoughts that treated another person as a substitute for one’s spouse. Those who followed him must be people of integrity, keeping their promises without excuses. When others lied, cheated, or hated them, they were to forgive. God had forgiven them far more than anyone else could owe them, Jesus said, and they were to offer that same forgiveness in return.

When Jesus said he intended to be in Jerusalem for Passover, the rest of us warned him it was dangerous. I kept quiet. We set out for Bethany, where we could stay and travel into the city for the feast, and stopped in Jericho for the Sabbath. The next morning, a crowd followed us out, eager for Jesus to heal them. At the back, a blind beggar kept calling, “Jesus, Son of David, have mercy on me,” while people tried to silence him. Jesus stopped and asked us to bring him forward. His name was Bartimaeus, and Jesus knew that his father, Timaeus, had recently died, leaving his son alone.

When Jesus asked what he wanted, Bartimaeus said he wanted to see. Jesus warned him that seeing would not immediately mean understanding: he had spent his life imagining what things looked like, and a new world would be strange. Bartimaeus opened his eyes and saw, but confusion and fear crossed his face. Jesus told him to close them and open them again. This time, the man recognized Jesus and looked up at the blue sky, delighted by its beauty. It was another gift that reached beyond the miracle itself.

On the road toward Bethany, Jesus again spoke of betrayal and arrest, though none of us could imagine what the coming days would bring. He sent Thomas and Thaddaeus ahead to Bethphage to find a donkey and its colt. If anyone questioned them, they were to say that the Lord needed the animals. When they returned with them, Jesus mounted the young colt. As we entered Jerusalem, people spread cloaks and palm branches along the road, shouting, “Hosanna, blessed is the one who comes in the name of the Lord.” For once, the crowd seemed to recognize who Jesus was, rather than simply seeking what he could do for them. Pharisees demanded that he quiet them, but he said that if the people were silent, the rocks would cry out. At the temple gates, however, his mood changed. “Oh, Jerusalem,” he said, wishing the story did not have to end this way.

The next day, Jesus returned to the temple, troubled by the marketplace that had taken over its courtyards. He braided pieces of rope into a whip, then drove the animals toward the gates and overturned the merchants’ tables. Coins scattered as people scrambled to contain the animals and recover their money. Priests rushed in, protesting that the sellers had a right to be there. Jesus answered that the temple was meant to be a holy house of prayer, not a marketplace and den of thieves. Watching him confront the priests, I felt certain he had crossed a line they could not ignore.

We spent the next several days in Jerusalem, with Jesus teaching at the temple by day and returning to Bethany at night. He kept telling us that the chief priests were plotting his death. It seemed impossible: the crowds who had welcomed him would surely protect him. Near the end of the week, Jesus told the others to remain in Bethany while he took the twelve into the city for Passover. He sent John and me ahead to prepare the meal at a house where the owner would meet us. We found Abigail and her teenage son, Mark, waiting. Mark led us upstairs to a large room and answered our questions about the arrangements with a stream of questions of his own. He was so eager to meet Jesus that he asked his mother to let him help serve, rather than go to another family celebration.

When Jesus arrived with the others, the meal began in a way none of us expected. He asked Mark for a basin and water, then knelt to wash our feet. I protested that washing feet was not his place, but he told me I did not yet understand. He was showing that we belonged to him, though accepting the gesture was our choice. Afterward, we argued over who should wash his feet, each of us suddenly wanting to serve him. Jesus gave that honor to Mark, who was beaming.

At the table, Jesus blessed the Passover bread and told us that from then on we should remember him whenever we ate it. The bread, he said, represented his body, which would be broken for us. He spoke of the cup in the same way: it represented his blood, soon to be shed for our salvation. The celebration had become an announcement of his death. Then he said that one of us would betray him before morning. We protested all at once that none of us would do such a thing. Jesus looked toward Judas Iscariot and told him to go and do what he had to do. I assumed Judas was going to pay Abigail for the meal, and followed the others into the night.

As we walked toward the garden, I tried to persuade Jesus that it did not have to end this way. He said that soon I would be alone, but I insisted that I would stay with him even if it meant dying. Jesus answered that he did not need me to die for him; he needed me to live for him. Before the rooster crowed twice, he said, I would deny him three times. In the garden, he took John, James, and me farther in and asked us to pray while he sought his Father. Exhausted, I leaned against a tree and fell asleep. When Jesus woke me, Judas had arrived with guards from the high priest. He identified Jesus with a kiss.

I reacted without thinking, drawing my short sword and striking at the nearest guard. I cut off the man’s ear, then realized I might have killed him and ruined my life. Jesus told me to put the weapon away. He picked up the ear and restored it, stopping the bleeding and the man’s cries. Then the guards tied Jesus’ hands and led him away. I looked around for the others, but they had scattered. I followed at a distance.

They took Jesus to Caiaphas’s house, where priests, elders, and religious leaders had gathered. By the fire, I heard that they wanted Jesus dead but needed a charge Rome would act on. People were twisting his words and searching for witnesses. A servant girl recognized me as one of Jesus’ followers. I denied knowing what she meant, then slipped into the shadows. Later, another man noticed my Galilean accent and challenged me again. I swore I did not know Jesus personally, then turned away as dawn began to break. The night had brought me face to face with the fear Jesus had predicted, and I had answered it by disowning the man I loved and followed.

Want the Full Experience?

This summary includes Key Takeaways, Chapter Summaries, Notable Quotes, Who Should Read This, and a professional AI-narrated audio version — available with a paid listing.

The author can upgrade this listing to unlock all sections.